Skip to content
GDPR guide

A Google Analytics alternative built for GDPR

Most teams look for a Google Analytics alternative for one reason: the consent banner. If analytics sets cookies, the ePrivacy rules (in Germany § 25 TDDDG) normally require consent first, and GA4 then only measures visitors who accept. Here are the five checks that matter for a GDPR-friendly tool, how to compare vendors, and how to switch without losing your history.

PureMetrixLast reviewed 6 min read13 sources checked

Why teams look for an alternative

Google Analytics 4 is powerful and free. But in the EU it usually comes with a consent banner, a share of visitors who decline, US data transfers to explain in your privacy policy, and a reporting interface many small teams find hard to use. For a company website, a blog or a small shop, that is often more than needed.

The typical goals behind the search are simple: complete visitor numbers, fewer consent prompts, data that stays in the EU, and a dashboard that answers "where do visitors come from and what do they do?" in a few seconds.

Five checks for a GDPR-friendly analytics tool

  1. No cookies or device identifiers. Nothing is stored on or read from the visitor's device for analytics. This is what removes the consent requirement of § 25 TDDDG for analytics.
  2. EU processing. Visitor data is processed on servers in the EU, ideally by a provider without a US parent company, so no third-country transfer needs to be justified.
  3. A data processing agreement (DPA) under Art. 28 GDPR is available before you start, with a list of subprocessors.
  4. Data minimisation. No full IP addresses stored, no cross-site profiles, no advertising use, and unique visitors counted for a short period only.
  5. A small script. Fewer bytes keep Core Web Vitals healthy and reduce what runs in the visitor's browser.

Cookieless is not the same as "no GDPR"

An IP address can be personal data even if it is hashed immediately. You still need a legal basis (usually legitimate interest, Art. 6(1)(f) GDPR), a DPA and an accurate privacy policy.

GA4 and PureMetrix compared

CheckGoogle Analytics 4PureMetrix
CookiesSets first-party cookies such as _ga; with consent mode, cookieless pings when consent is deniedNo visitor cookies
HostingGoogle infrastructure; Google LLC is a US company (DPF-certified)EU servers (Hetzner)
Consent banner for analyticsUsually required in the EUDesigned to work without one for analytics; check your setup with your DPO
Visitors measuredThose who consent; the rest is modelledAll visitors
ScriptGoogle tag, considerably largerUnder 3 KB, optional proxy on your own domain
PriceFree (GA4 360 for large companies)From €6/month after a 14-day trial, no card needed
DepthVery broad: audiences, Ads integration, modelling, BigQueryFocused: pageviews, sources, goals, funnels and WooCommerce revenue (Growth and up)

For a feature-by-feature view, see PureMetrix vs Google Analytics.

Questions to ask any vendor

Whichever tool you consider, these questions quickly show how serious a vendor is about data protection:

  • Where exactly are events processed and stored, and who owns the infrastructure?
  • Is there a US parent company or a US subprocessor that receives visitor data?
  • Is a DPA available, and is the subprocessor list public?
  • Does the script store anything in cookies, localStorage or similar?
  • How are unique visitors counted, and for how long can a visitor be recognised?
  • Can raw IP addresses be retrieved later, or are they discarded?
  • Can staff and bots be excluded from the numbers?

For PureMetrix the answers are on the EU hosting page, in how cookieless tracking works and in the DPA.

The main alternatives at a glance

ToolTypeData locationPrice from
PureMetrixCookieless serviceEU (Hetzner)€6/month
PlausibleCookieless service, open sourceEU$9/month
Simple AnalyticsCookieless serviceEUFree (hobby); $20/month
etrackerAnalytics suiteGermany€10.80/month, 12-month term
MatomoSuite, open sourceSelf-hosted or Matomo CloudOn-Premise free
PugProduct analytics, open sourcePug Cloud in the EU, or self-hostedFree up to 100k events/month

Prices checked on 9 November 2026. Detailed reviews: best cookieless analytics tools and Google Analytics alternatives compared.

What you gain and what you give up

You gainYou give up
DataMeasured numbers for all visitorsLong-lived user IDs and cross-device journeys
ComplianceNo consent step for analytics, EU-only processingNothing, as long as your privacy policy and DPA are updated
SpeedA script under 3 KB—
MarketingClear sources and campaignsGoogle Ads audiences, remarketing and modelling
ReportingA dashboard you understand in secondsGA4's custom explorations and BigQuery export

When GA4 is still the right tool

A cookieless tool cannot replace advertising features. Stay with GA4 (or run it alongside) if:

  • you rely on Google Ads audiences, remarketing or conversion modelling,
  • you need BigQuery exports or user-level analysis across months,
  • your consent banner stays anyway because of other tools such as ad pixels.

Many teams end up with both: GA4 behind the banner for advertising, and a cookieless tool for complete traffic numbers.

Switching in five steps

  1. Start the 14-day PureMetrix trial and add your site (no card needed).
  2. Install the WordPress plugin or the snippet, and exclude your own visits.
  3. Recreate your key goals: thank-you pages, form submissions, downloads, purchases.
  4. Run both tools in parallel for two to four weeks and compare trends.
  5. Update your privacy policy, sign the DPA, and remove GA4 when you are ready. See switch from GA4.

Expect different numbers

A cookieless tool usually shows more visitors than GA4 behind a banner, because it counts everyone. Unique visitors are counted per day, so returning-visitor figures are not directly comparable.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best GDPR-compliant alternative to Google Analytics?

For European websites that want complete numbers without a consent step for analytics, a cookieless tool hosted in the EU is the simplest choice. PureMetrix fits WordPress and WooCommerce sites; Plausible is a strong open-source option.

Do I still need a privacy policy with cookieless analytics?

Yes. You must describe the processing, the legal basis and the provider in your privacy policy, and sign a DPA under Art. 28 GDPR.

Can I import my Google Analytics history?

Not every tool imports GA4 data. Export the reports you need from GA4 before you remove it, and run both tools in parallel for a few weeks so you have overlapping data. PureMetrix can import older numbers via CSV.

Will my numbers match GA4?

No, and that is expected. Cookieless tools count all visitors, while GA4 behind a banner only measures those who consent. Compare trends and goals rather than absolute totals.

Is an EU-hosted tool automatically GDPR compliant?

No tool is automatically compliant. EU hosting largely settles the third-country transfer question, as long as no subprocessor outside the EU/EEA can access visitor data, including remotely. Cookieless tracking removes the device-storage question for analytics, but you still need a legal basis, a DPA and transparency.

How much does PureMetrix cost?

Starter costs €6 a month for 10,000 pageviews and one site. Growth (€14) adds WooCommerce revenue, funnels and up to three sites; Business (€29) adds client reports, white-label and the Stats API. Every account starts with a 14-day trial.

Try cookieless analytics on your own site

14 days free, no credit card. EU-hosted on Hetzner, set up in a few minutes with the WordPress plugin or a snippet.

Start the 14-day trial See pricing